You Yell at Your Kids Because It Works

{This post may contain affiliate links. See disclosure.}

Do you yell at your kids? Do you know why you yell? Why you do you keep returning to yelling as a parenting strategy, even when you don't want to?

Do you ever have one of those days? You know the days I'm talking about. The days when you lose your temper and yell at the kids? Maybe you're tired. Maybe you're frustrated or overwhelmed.

But no matter what the case, you always feel rotten afterwards. No more yelling, you determine. And you promise yourself not to lose your temper again. But does it work?

Why Yelling Works

If you're going to make changes, it isn't enough to just determine to do things differently and employ "will power". You have to get down to the bottom of how you got into those habits in the first place. 

I'll tell you why you yell at your kids. You yell at them because, on some level, it's working for you. Generally habits develop because we're getting some payoff from it, even if it is temporary.

Do you yell at your kids? Do you know why you yell? Why you do you keep returning to yelling as a parenting strategy, even when you don't want to?

Here are some things that yelling actually can accomplish ...

  • yelling can release pent-up stress and emotional energy
  • yelling can give the gratification of hurting someone who has hurt you
  • yelling can motivate people to do the things you want them to do (faster)

This isn't a pleasant list to read over. It wasn't a pleasant list to write, as I've drawn all these motivations from my own heart and my own experience of parenting.

The Bible Says Yelling Works

I bet you're familiar with this verse from the book of James.

Know this, my beloved brothers: let every person be quick to hear, slow to speak, slow to anger; (James 1:19)

But have you connected that idea with the verse that follows?

for the anger of man does not produce the righteousness of God. (James 1:20)

Why on earth would God need to tell us that anger doesn't produce righteousness? Well, because, while it doesn't produce the righteousness of God, it does produce something. We wouldn't be tempted to fall back into anger and yelling if it didn't produce something that, at least from a certain perspective, seems to give us what we want.

It might produce kids who appear to behave better (outwardly). It might produce kids who feel very sad about what they did (but not necessarily for the right reasons). It might seem to relieve the pent up emotional energy of overwhelm (while creating other overwhelming problems).

We need God to remind us that yelling doesn't actually produce what we (should) most want for our children: God-honoring righteousness.

Leaving Old Habits without New Ones to Replace Them

If you want to quit a destructive habit, you need to replace it with a new, healthy habit. The most effective replacements are those which meet the same need, but with a different method.

My husband and I once watched a documentary about women who were in a special rehab program for treatment of eating disorders. The counselors spent a great deal of time talking to them about body image, nutrition, self-care, and more.

The women in the clinic were carefully supervised to prevent them from engaging in destructive behaviors and personally encouraged to eat healthy meals. One woman had reached the goals of her treatment program and was scheduled to be discharged.

The documentary followed her home ... where she lived as an unemployed, single mother of two toddlers. Immediately, the weight of this situation hit me.

This woman had spent months practicing new eating habits to replace the old. She'd practiced new patterns of internal dialogue about her body to replace the old, damaging self-talk.

But she'd had no practice with new strategies for coping with the stress and overwhelm of single-parenting toddlers. How could she have in a carefully controlled rehab facility?

Within twenty-four hours, this struggling mom had returned to her former methods of handling the overwhelm. I don't share this to shame her or to criticize the clinic, but it was an eye-opening moment for me.

Getting Strategies Set

It's not enough to have a desire to quit yelling. it's not enough to just feel really crummy after you fall into that pattern yet again. Neither of those actually sets you on a course for positive change.

Instead, you need some practical, prepared approaches that can help you to tackle the parenting dilemmas that occur in your home each and every day. We'll talk more about these strategies in the next two posts in this series. (Find them here and here.)

Lynna Sutherland

Lynna believes that the gospel moves the homeschool mom from performance to possibility. She offers support for moms overwhelmed by homeschooling multiple ages and distracted by constant sibling conflict. Ditch what slows you down and look to Jesus. (Hebrews 12:1-2)
  • Those Scriptures cut deep. Thank you for this article. I anticipate the next!